Real Madrid‘s new Social Disciplinary Regulation has drawn criticism from club members over provisions that some fear could allow sanctions for public criticism of directors and players. The updated code took effect on 1 August following approval by the Junta Directiva on 28 July, with members notified the previous day.
The regulation replaces a 2017 version and introduces specific infractions concerning conduct towards the club and its representatives. Articles 9.7 and 10.18 have attracted particular scrutiny from the membership. Article 9.7 classifies failing to show due respect to club representatives through actions, gestures or words as a very serious offence. Meanwhile, Article 10.18 covers verbal or written acts capable of damaging the respect, dignity or image of the club or those who represent it.
Some socios interpret these clauses as a mechanism to restrict criticism of the board and playing staff, particularly following the recent re-election of president Florentino Pérez. Under the new framework, the Comisión de Disciplina Social holds exclusive authority to open and investigate disciplinary cases involving members. Any proposed sanctions require final approval from the Junta Directiva, which exercises this power under Articles 55 and 57 of the club’s statutes.
The club maintains that the updated regulation primarily addresses modern operational challenges, including technological changes and the irregular resale of season tickets and match credentials. According to the preamble, the code modernises disciplinary frameworks to reflect current realities rather than to silence dissent.
Comparisons with other major Spanish clubs reveal notable differences in governance approach. Barcelona‘s statutes reference freedom of expression alongside obligations to respect the honour of directors and players, but do not specify detailed infractions or corresponding sanctions. Atlético de Madrid employs similarly broad member regulations without the precise disciplinary classifications and sanctioning procedures now adopted by Real Madrid.
The framework places specific responsibilities with the Director of the Área Social, José Luis Sánchez, and the Director of Legal Services, Javier López Farré, as outlined in Article 55 of the club’s governing documents.